Comparisons - Page 3 of 3 - Mack Robertson

My Choice These are both great beach tents. but when it comes to Neso vs Shibumi, I would choose the Shibumi Shade. Technical Comparison Shibumi282 Reviews(read now)Neso4784 Reviews(read now)Pros:Easy setupCompact, lightweight storagePros:Easy SetupCompact, lightweight storageLots of color variationsSturdy in the windCons:UnstableNoisy in the windOne style availableCons:Doesn’t come with shovelOverall:Designed and sewn in America, Shibumi Shade is lightweight, easy to set up, and provides shade for everyone. Overall:Large and in charge, the Neso Grande beach tent is made out of a Lycra/Nylon blend that’s UPF 50+, water resistant, and weighs only 6.5 lbs. Key Differences The Neso Grande is a well-crafted beach tent, no doubt about it. It rivals my all-time favorite pick by Sun Ninja. The process is simple, you lay the tent flat and fill the corner bags with sand (remember a shovel for a faster process) then prop the shade up with 2 included support poles. Neso stays put throughout the day, and the Grande version fits 4 people. Shibumi’s “free flowing design” is an attractive claim, but unfortunately the science behind the product isn’t up to par. did not cooperate with even a mild beach breeze. Shibumi also only utilizes one pole, which is simply not enough. The curved design is aesthetically pleasing, but it minimizes the amount of usable space underneath. Plus, the fabric remains loose and leads to a constant flapping noise. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=amhTanHD9Sc The Best Beach Tent is the Shibumi Shade In comparison to Neso, Shibumi takes the cake in the competition for best beach tent. The Shibumi Shade is simple to set up, stays put in the sand, and covers more usable ground than the Neso. When I'm headed to the beach, if I have to make a choice between these two shades, I'm grabbing my Shibumi. Additional Questions Are Neso tents a good choice? Absolutely, Neso tents are a splendid choice for beach lovers and sun seekers alike! In my personal experience, these tents are built to last and offer an excellent blend of durability and style. The Neso's lightweight design has always made it a breeze for me to carry to the beach — even when I'm alone and don't have an extra pair of hands to help. What truly impresses me, however, is the amount of sun coverage it provides. I had taken a crowd of my relatives to the beach last summer, and everyone was comfortably ensconced in the cooling shade that my Neso tent generously provided. So, if you're considering a long-lasting beach tent or thinking of surprising someone with a useful gift, you should definitely be eyeing the Neso. It's a testament to the joy of outdoor living! Can Shibumi function without any wind? Interestingly, the unique design of the Shibumi® beach shades does require a bit of wind to work effectively. I was at the beach a few years ago, on an unusually still day. With virtually no wind blowing, I initially struggled to set up the Shibumi shade. However, as soon as the afternoon sea breeze picked up, the Shibumi filled out beautifully, providing us with a generous patch of shade. So, yes, while Shibumi beach shades function best with some wind, it offers an innovative way to seek respite from the sun! Is it worth investing in a Shibumi? If you frequent the beach and have been looking for a lightweight yet versatile shade provider, a Shibumi Shade is definitely worth the investment. I recall my friend Sean, who was initially skeptical about spending a hefty $250 on a beach canopy. But once he saw how easily the Shibumi set up, and how it provided stable shade without getting blown away by the wind, he was completely sold. With a Shibumi, you'll no longer have to worry about chasing after your beach umbrella or struggling with bulky beach tents. It's super light to carry and offers robust sun protection — a worthwhile purchase for any beach-goer. Which beaches disallow Shibumi? Shibumi states that its beach shades are permitted on almost every U.S. beach. There are, however, a few exceptions, notably some beaches on the Grand Strand and a particular beach in Delaware. But the versatility of the Shibumi comes into play here — unlike rigid structures, it's designed so it won't catch the wind and cause trouble. The company emphasizes this on its website, assuring users that a Shibumi will never fly away in a gust or roll down the beach, causing havoc. This design consideration is exactly why I always favor my Shibumi for windy beach days. It's the peace of mind a beach-goer needs!